Kalen DeBoer’s first year coaching Alabama largely went unnoticed, but the challenges within the offense, compounded by Jalen Milroe’s struggles, were significant. While Milroe faced criticism for interceptions and inconsistent play, some of the blame also falls on DeBoer, who needed to put his quarterback in better situations to succeed. Despite this, the focus has now shifted to the future, with fans hopeful that DeBoer’s offensive expertise and new talent could bring a turnaround. The coming season could mark a significant shift, much like the movie Top Gun: Maverick, where a fresh perspective revitalized the entire team.
DeBoer, an offensive-minded coach, faced scrutiny for his team’s lackluster offensive performance, especially in critical games like the loss to Michigan. Milroe was under the spotlight for that game, which highlighted his inconsistencies and the team’s inability to adapt effectively. Even with a strategy built around Milroe’s mobility, the approach failed to deliver results. Reflecting on this, DeBoer admitted, “We certainly put a lot on his shoulders,” indicating that Milroe carried more responsibility than he could handle.
With Milroe now heading to the NFL, Alabama’s offense is set for a reset. DeBoer’s attention turns to Keelon Russell, a standout high school player and National Gatorade Player of the Year. Russell, with over 4,100 passing yards and 55 touchdowns in his senior season, enters Tuscaloosa as one of the most exciting quarterback prospects. Fans are optimistic that Russell’s skillset will provide the much-needed spark to rejuvenate Alabama’s offense. His arrival has sparked a heated quarterback competition, and the pressure is on DeBoer to integrate him effectively.
However, DeBoer’s critics argue that his handling of Milroe was a missed opportunity to adjust and build a stronger offensive system. Milroe’s performance against Michigan, with consecutive incompletions, stood out as a low point. Critics also point to other factors, like a struggling defense in games like the one against Vanderbilt, as further evidence of a disjointed team.
Adding to Alabama’s woes is a transfer portal exodus that has left the roster depleted. Over 19 players have transferred out, including key contributors like running back Justice Haynes, linebacker Keanu Koht, and wide receiver Emmanuel Henderson. Offensive tackle Elijah Pritchett, who played 13 games and over 600 snaps, also declared for the portal, delivering another blow to the team. On top of this, left guard Tyler Booker has announced his entry into the 2025 NFL Draft, leaving Alabama’s offensive line with major gaps.
These departures have increased the pressure on DeBoer, who now faces the daunting task of rebuilding the roster while addressing the team’s glaring weaknesses. Analyst Paul Finebaum has been particularly critical, suggesting that DeBoer’s job could be in jeopardy if Alabama fails to make the playoffs next season. The stakes are high, and with so many key positions in flux, DeBoer’s ability to navigate these challenges will determine whether he can secure Alabama’s return to dominance.
As fans debate whether Keelon Russell can be the savior Alabama needs, the weight of expectations continues to mount on Kalen DeBoer. For now, the road ahead is uncertain, but the coming season will undoubtedly test his leadership and adaptability.