The Los Angeles Dodgers are facing challenges in their pursuit to re-sign free-agent outfielder Teoscar Hernandez. Negotiations have stalled due to disagreements over key contract terms, with Hernandez reportedly taking a firm stance against deferred payments. This approach contrasts with the Dodgers’ longstanding practice of structuring deals with deferred payments to maintain financial flexibility. Notable contracts for players like Mookie Betts and Freddie Freeman have included such arrangements. However, Hernandez appears focused on securing his earnings upfront, prioritizing financial stability in the short term.
The dispute over deferred payments is not the only sticking point in the negotiations. Reports indicate that differences over the contract’s annual average value (AAV) and signing bonus have also complicated discussions. Despite these hurdles, Dodgers manager Dave Roberts recently expressed optimism about the team’s chances of bringing Hernandez back, stating that negotiations are progressing. Roberts encouraged fans to remain hopeful, hinting that an agreement may soon be finalized.
Securing Hernandez is a priority for the Dodgers as they navigate a competitive offseason. The team has significant goals, including targeting Shohei Ohtani and addressing their pitching rotation, making it essential to solidify their outfield lineup early. Hernandez would fill a critical role, especially following the departure of J.D. Martinez and uncertainties surrounding other outfield contributors.
Industry speculation suggests the potential deal with Hernandez could be worth $60–70 million over three or four years. A compromise may involve the Dodgers offering a higher AAV or structuring the signing bonus to accommodate Hernandez’s preference against deferred payments. Such adjustments would allow the team to retain financial flexibility while meeting the player’s demands.
Hernandez’s strong market value stems from his impressive 2024 performance, during which he hit 33 home runs, recorded 99 RBIs, and played a pivotal role in the Dodgers’ World Series victory. His combination of power and defensive capabilities makes him a top target in free agency, with other teams, such as the Boston Red Sox, reportedly showing interest. The Red Sox’s need for outfield strength positions them as a serious contender to lure Hernandez away from Los Angeles.
If the Dodgers fail to reach an agreement with Hernandez, they may explore alternative options. Free agents like Cody Bellinger, Michael Conforto, or Hunter Renfroe could be viable replacements. Bellinger’s versatility and recent offensive improvement make him a compelling choice, though he would likely come at a higher cost. Conforto offers a left-handed bat and a more budget-friendly alternative. Additionally, the Dodgers could consider trade opportunities to address their outfield needs.
Ultimately, Hernandez’s next move—whether re-signing with the Dodgers or joining another team—could significantly impact the balance of power in Major League Baseball heading into the 2025 season. His combination of affordability and high-impact performance makes him a valuable asset in a competitive offseason market.