Alabama’s football season has been a rollercoaster of emotions. Despite suffering three losses, the team salvaged some pride by winning the Iron Bowl against the Auburn Tigers. However, any relief from this victory was short-lived as their hopes for a playoff spot were dashed. Ranked No. 11 in the College Football Playoff (CFP) rankings, just ahead of SMU and Miami, the Crimson Tide’s season still ended in disappointment. Amid this turmoil, head coach Kalen DeBoer found himself under intense scrutiny from fans, many of whom questioned his suitability for the role. While some argue that Alabama is in a rebuilding phase with a promising 2025 recruiting class, the fanbase remains dissatisfied and nostalgic for the Nick Saban era.
Nick Saban’s tenure at Alabama transformed the program into a powerhouse. Under his leadership, the team won numerous SEC championships and six national titles, establishing a standard of excellence that few could match. Saban’s retirement left a void that many feared would be difficult to fill. Kalen DeBoer, previously the head coach at Washington, stepped into the role knowing the challenges of succeeding a legend. Initially, he showed promise, but as the season unfolded, Alabama’s performance faltered, and the Tide’s playoff aspirations crumbled.
View this post on Instagram
The team suffered devastating losses, including a defeat to unranked Vanderbilt, a tough loss against Tennessee, and a crushing blow from Oklahoma. These setbacks left the Tide far below their usual standards and put DeBoer’s leadership under intense scrutiny. Alabama’s offense struggled with inconsistency throughout the season. While quarterback Jalen Milroe made mistakes, the larger issue was the offense’s inability to deliver consistently.
Despite the disappointing season, there was a moment of celebration when several Alabama players participated in their graduation ceremony. The event, marked by traditional collegiate festivities, featured DeBoer posing for photos with the graduates. However, fans were quick to critique DeBoer’s casual attire, noting that Nick Saban would have opted for a more formal appearance. Comments ranged from disappointment in DeBoer’s presentation to general nostalgia for Saban’s presence. Some fans even questioned whether DeBoer was suitable to represent the program at such events.
The comparisons between DeBoer and Saban extend beyond coaching performance to their demeanor, discipline, and style. Saban’s poker-faced professionalism and meticulous attention to detail left an indelible mark on the program, and many fans are struggling to embrace DeBoer’s more laid-back approach. As a result, even moments meant to celebrate the team’s achievements have become points of contention among the fanbase.
The constant comparisons and criticisms highlight the challenge of following a legendary coach like Nick Saban. Whether DeBoer can turn things around and win over the Alabama faithful in future seasons remains uncertain. For now, the Tide’s fanbase seems unwilling to let go of the past, making DeBoer’s tenure a challenging one both on and off the field.