The ongoing debate between Arch Manning and Quinn Ewers has been a hot topic in college football, especially after the recent SEC Championship game. Texas Longhorns fans have intensified their calls for a shift in quarterback leadership, urging head coach Steve Sarkisian to consider replacing Ewers with Manning. This discussion has been fueled by Ewers’ inconsistent performance throughout the season, including a lackluster showing in Texas’ 22-19 loss to Georgia in the SEC Championship game. The defeat not only dashed their hopes for a first-round bye but also raised questions about Ewers’ future with the Longhorns.
In the game against Georgia, Ewers threw for 358 yards and one touchdown but also had two costly interceptions. Additionally, he endured six sacks, a glaring blemish on his resume. While not all the blame falls solely on Ewers, his underwhelming performance has cast doubt on his ability to lead the team effectively. Reports indicate that Ewers is now weighing his options, contemplating whether to declare for the NFL Draft or enter the transfer portal to continue his college career elsewhere.
Quinn Ewers is reportedly “debating” on returning to college football and forgoing the NFL Draft yet again.
However, Texas is reportedly “ready” to move on to Arch Manning next season, which would prompt Ewers to enter the transfer portal.
Many NFL scouts reportedly believe… pic.twitter.com/EVpXjTMTli
— NFL Rookie Watch (@NFLRookieWatxh) December 12, 2024
The dilemma for Ewers is multifaceted. On one hand, he has another year of eligibility, but Texas appears ready to transition to Arch Manning as their starting quarterback. On the other hand, many NFL scouts believe that Ewers could benefit from another year in college to refine his skills. This situation mirrors the uncertainty faced by Alabama quarterback Jalen Milroe, who also must decide between entering the NFL Draft or transferring to another college program.
Meanwhile, Arch Manning has quietly made his case for a starting role. Despite being relegated to a backup position for most of the season, Manning has remained committed to Texas, rejecting offers from other programs to fulfill his dream of playing for the Longhorns. Sarkisian has faced criticism for his decision to keep Manning on the bench, especially after Ewers’ repeated struggles. Manning’s potential and the team’s national title aspirations may eventually force Sarkisian’s hand.
Sarkisian’s handling of Ewers has also been a point of contention. Some argue that Sarkisian’s indecisiveness has contributed to the quarterback’s lack of confidence. Despite Ewers showing resilience after a rough start to the season, including battling through injuries, critics believe Sarkisian’s support has been inconsistent. Former Heisman Trophy winner Johnny Manziel criticized the decision to sideline Ewers during a critical game, describing it as “weird” and questioning Sarkisian’s judgment.
The future remains uncertain for both Ewers and Manning. For Ewers, a move to the NFL or a new college program through the transfer portal appears inevitable, as his time with Texas seems to be coming to an unofficial end. For Manning, his time to take center stage may be near, but whether it will be enough to salvage Texas’ title hopes this season remains to be seen.