The idea of Mike Trout wearing a Yankees jersey at Yankee Stadium may seem far-fetched, but it has sparked speculation and excitement among fans. Although the odds of Trout joining the Yankees in 2025 are slim, the possibility of such a blockbuster trade has fueled discussions, especially with the Yankees still recovering from losing Juan Soto to their crosstown rivals, the New York Mets.
Rumors about Trout’s potential departure from the Los Angeles Angels have intensified, leading to trade suggestions ranging from plausible to wildly unrealistic. Given Trout’s roots in Millville, New Jersey, and his admiration for Yankees legend Derek Jeter, there’s a scenario where he might waive his full no-trade clause for a move to New York. As the most celebrated franchise in baseball, the Yankees could provide Trout with a fresh start closer to home.
However, questions about Trout’s value and health linger. A few years ago, such a trade would have been unthinkable, but the superstar has struggled to stay healthy, failing to complete a full season since 2019. Over the last two years, he has played in just over 100 games combined, raising doubts about his ability to return to MVP form as he approaches his age-33 season.
Navigating Mike Trout’s Contract
A potential trade would be complicated by Trout’s contract, a 12-year, $426.5 million deal signed in 2019. With over $37 million owed annually through 2030, the Yankees would likely balk at taking on the full financial burden. The Angels might have to cover a substantial portion of the contract or accept high-cost players from the Yankees in return.
One possible candidate is Marcus Stroman, who is due $18.3 million next year with a vesting option for 2026. Pairing Stroman with other cost-cutting measures, like offloading DJ LeMahieu’s remaining $30 million and managing Giancarlo Stanton’s significant contract, could make Trout’s salary more feasible for the Yankees.
What the Angels Would Need in Return
To land Trout, the Yankees would need to offer valuable assets to help the Angels rebuild. This could start with Spencer Jones, the Yankees’ No. 2 prospect. Jones, a 23-year-old outfielder known for his power and athleticism, hit 17 home runs with a .789 OPS at Double-A in 2024 and is expected to begin 2025 in Triple-A. While he may not replicate Trout’s superstar production, he represents a promising piece for the Angels’ future.
The Yankees could also include fringe Major League-ready relievers to sweeten the deal. Pitchers like Clayton Beeter and Yeondrys Gomez, who made appearances with the Yankees in 2024, could bolster the Angels’ bullpen and provide immediate contributions.
Conclusion
While the logistics of a Mike Trout trade to the Yankees are daunting, the idea is captivating for fans on both sides. It would require significant financial maneuvering, as well as the Yankees parting with top prospects and valuable players. Despite Trout’s health concerns, his potential upside could make him worth the gamble for a franchise eager to reclaim dominance in the league. Whether the Yankees pursue this bold move remains to be seen, but the speculation alone adds intrigue to the baseball offseason.