Alabama’s College Football Playoff (CFP) spot has sparked significant debate, especially after their impressive victory over Auburn in the Iron Bowl. The win has placed Alabama at No. 11 in the latest CFP rankings, but many in the college football community question the fairness of this ranking, suggesting it reflects favoritism rather than performance. Despite Alabama’s win, critics argue that the committee’s decision to rank Alabama over teams like Miami is unjust, with many feeling that the Crimson Tide’s resume doesn’t justify their placement.
Miami fans and analysts, in particular, are upset about Alabama’s ranking, citing the Tide’s losses to teams like Oklahoma and pointing out that Miami has a better overall record. Critics argue that Alabama’s weak loss to Oklahoma shouldn’t be overshadowed by Miami’s own two losses to Syracuse and Georgia Tech. This has led to further frustration, especially when contrasting how both teams performed against similar opponents, such as USF. Miami showed a stronger performance in that game, yet the committee continues to reward Alabama, whose schedule was considered stronger overall.
Cote: Ranking 9-3 Alabama over 10-2 Miami shows flaws in 12-team College Football Playoff | Opinion https://t.co/wLKc1f4AZm
— The Island Packet (@islandpacket) December 5, 2024
Mike Ryan Ruiz, a co-host on The Dan Le Batard Show, expressed his disbelief, highlighting the inconsistencies in the CFP committee’s reasoning. He pointed out the difference in Alabama’s and Miami’s records against top teams, with Alabama having a 3-1 record against current top 25 teams, compared to Miami’s 0-1. He also noted that Miami’s stronger performance against USF seemed to be ignored in favor of Alabama’s schedule strength, despite both teams having struggled in certain games.
Despite these grievances, the committee, led by Warde Manuel, defended Alabama’s ranking. Manuel emphasized that the tougher schedule Alabama faced was a key factor in their positioning. He argued that Alabama’s victories over top-tier teams like Georgia outweighed Miami’s weaker schedule and lack of big wins. Alabama’s strong record against teams with winning records further solidified their ranking, according to Manuel.
Despite the arguments and complaints, Alabama’s place in the CFP remains tenuous. A loss by SMU could shake up the rankings and threaten their spot in the playoff. The controversy surrounding Alabama’s ranking continues to stir debate, with many questioning whether the committee’s decisions are based on merit or on a longstanding bias toward SEC teams like Alabama.