The NFL Draft typically creates a dramatic atmosphere, full of high-stakes decisions that could shape a franchise’s future. This year, however, the drama shifted from the usual focus on who went first to the surprise omission of Shedeur Sanders. The Colorado quarterback, who was expected to be a top pick, found his draft stock plummet to the point where, after two days, 102 players were selected before him. His absence shocked analysts, fans, and even politicians, but the most notable reaction came from Jerry Jones, the Dallas Cowboys’ owner, who has a long-standing relationship with Deion Sanders, Shedeur’s father.
Jones expressed admiration for Shedeur, emphasizing the legacy of winning and character in the Sanders family. He noted his personal knowledge of Shedeur’s character, having watched him play and seen his family’s history of success. Yet, despite his praise, Jones did not select Shedeur in the draft. Instead, the Cowboys picked backup QB Joe Milton, leaving the door open for other teams to consider the young prospect. Jones hinted that teams overlooking Shedeur were missing an opportunity, referencing his ties to Deion Sanders, but ultimately, he passed on him in favor of other needs.
Shedeur’s draft prospects had once been glowing. With a college season that included over 4,000 passing yards, 37 touchdowns, and an impressive 74% completion rate, he was thought to be a potential top-five pick. Yet, five quarterbacks were chosen before him, with some questioning his performance in interviews and his on-field traits, including his tendency to hold onto the ball too long and his inconsistent pro-day throws. Some coaches and executives criticized him for what they described as “entitled” behavior and a lack of development as a player.
Cowboys owner Jerry Jones on Shedeur Sanders not being drafted in the first three rounds: “We thought and evaluated him extremely high in this draft.” Jones added that they already have Dak Prescott. Jones then spoke at length about how highly he thinks of the Sanders family pic.twitter.com/BLBuXzZMpI
— Jon Machota (@jonmachota) April 26, 2025
Despite the criticism, figures like Patrick Mahomes and even former President Donald Trump expressed support for Shedeur, calling his omission “crazy.” As the draft wore on, it became clear that his fall might not be due to his skills alone but to the complexities of his legacy. Teams may have been cautious about drafting a quarterback whose name would bring heavy media scrutiny, not just because of his performance, but due to his connection to his famous father. This added layer of fame and expectation may have played a significant role in teams’ hesitation to select him.
Still, Shedeur’s story is far from over. Some teams, like the Steelers and Jets, are considered potential wild cards for picking him up later in the draft. Despite his drop, there’s still belief in his potential. His resilience could be the key to a future comeback, following the example set by other late-round quarterbacks like Tom Brady and Dak Prescott, who turned their draft-night disappointments into legendary careers.
Ultimately, the question remains: Did NFL teams miss out on a future star by passing on Shedeur Sanders, or was the decision justified? Only time will tell if the risk of drafting a player with such a high-profile legacy will pay off. For now, Sanders’ fall serves as a reminder of the pressure that comes with fame in the NFL, as well as the fear of taking a gamble on a name that carries so much weight.