WrestleMania 41 Night One ended in shocking fashion as Paul Heyman betrayed both Roman Reigns and CM Punk, aligning himself with Seth Rollins.
In the final moments of the Triple Threat match involving Reigns, Punk, and Rollins, Heyman stunned the WWE Universe by delivering low blows to both Reigns and Punk. Just as fans were reeling from that betrayal, Rollins added another layer to the moment with a brutal chair shot to Roman Reigns—bringing back memories of the infamous Shield betrayal from 2014. This unexpected twist wrapped up the saga with a moment many are calling “The Heist of the Century 2.0.”
Here are three possible reasons why Paul Heyman chose to side with Seth Rollins at WrestleMania 41:
—
3. The Rock may have influenced Heyman’s actions
Speculation is spreading among fans based on a small but telling detail during Seth Rollins’s WrestleMania 41 entrance. Rollins used a flamethrower, much like the one The Rock used during his WrestleMania 32 entrance. Observant fans believe this could hint at The Rock playing a behind-the-scenes role in orchestrating Heyman’s betrayal.
In recent weeks, Rollins has also been seen wearing outfits reminiscent of The Rock’s style—including black half jackets and turtlenecks. These subtle homages have led to the theory that The Rock may have given Heyman the directive to turn on Reigns and Punk as part of a broader storyline that might unfold on Night Two or in the weeks that follow.
— Xero (@4YouWrestling) April 20, 2025
2. Heyman realized Reigns and Punk were using him
Throughout the buildup to the Triple Threat match, tension lingered over which competitor Heyman would side with. Reigns and Punk each tried to manipulate the situation, both using Heyman as a psychological weapon against the other.
Being a veteran of the wrestling business and a WWE Hall of Famer, Heyman likely recognized that he was being used. Rather than continue being a pawn, he decided to reclaim control of the narrative. By siding with Rollins—who appeared more focused and ruthless—Heyman demonstrated that he was still a master strategist, choosing the person who offered him the best future.
Speechless. #WrestleMania pic.twitter.com/lXfC10HkHP
— WWE India (@WWEIndia) April 20, 2025
1. Heyman sought revenge for past betrayals
The betrayal may also have been deeply personal for Paul Heyman. In the past, both Roman Reigns and CM Punk left Heyman behind when it suited them.
After Reigns lost to Cody Rhodes at last year’s WrestleMania, he left without saying a word, abandoning Heyman, who was left to face the wrath of the Bloodline 2.0 alone. Similarly, CM Punk distanced himself from Heyman years ago when he left WWE, only to later return and ask for favors—seemingly betraying the loyalty they once shared.
Heyman’s actions at WrestleMania 41 could be seen as the culmination of a long-brewing plan for revenge. By betraying both men on the grandest stage of them all, he made a statement—reminding everyone that he is a kingmaker, and that betrayal cuts both ways.
—
The events of WrestleMania 41 Night One will undoubtedly have long-term consequences, with fans eagerly awaiting what comes next in this high-stakes storyline.