Jordan Spieth has been going through a tough period in his golfing career, primarily due to a persistent wrist injury. In an effort to get back to form, he underwent surgery in late August 2024. He hoped to return to full strength with his long-time caddie, Michael Greller, by his side. Greller has been Spieth’s caddie for 14 years, and their partnership dates back to 2011 when they first teamed up at the U.S. Junior Amateur. Their connection has remained strong ever since. Although Greller briefly caddied for Max Homa earlier in January, sparking some rumors, it turned out to be a one-time arrangement. Now, both Spieth and Greller are back on the course, trying to regain Spieth’s top form.
However, things took a dramatic turn during the third round of the 2025 Valero Texas Open. Spieth made a bogey on hole 12, a moment that appeared to change the momentum of his game. Many fans noticed his struggles, particularly with reading the wind, which drew strong criticism on social media. One tweet that gained attention labeled Spieth as “an embarrassment to the sport of golf,” criticizing his inability to judge wind conditions and blaming Greller for not stepping in effectively as a caddie.
This incident led to renewed discussions about whether Spieth should consider replacing Greller. A fan poll asked whether Spieth should part ways with his long-time caddie. Options ranged from fully supporting a change to believing their partnership is still solid. Others suggested a change might be warranted only if results don’t improve.
This isn’t the first time a golfer’s caddie has come under fire. Rory McIlroy’s caddie, Harry Diamond, has also faced criticism due to McIlroy’s extended major championship drought. McIlroy’s last major win was in 2014, and despite consistent performances, he has fallen short in several close calls, including the past six U.S. Opens. Some fans feel that while Diamond has been a loyal companion, he may not be the best fit for handling the high-stakes moments.
Back to Spieth, fan reactions continued pouring in. Some believed Greller should share the blame for Spieth’s struggles. Others stressed that a “good caddie” is expected to anticipate conditions like wind and guide the golfer better. A few fans directly stated that Greller has been part of the problem for a while and that Spieth needs someone more assertive to help him become competitive again.
Interestingly, Spieth wouldn’t be the first golfer to part ways with a trusted caddie in search of better results. Matt Fitzpatrick recently ended his six-year partnership with Billy Foster after failing to make the cut at The PLAYERS Championship. Foster confirmed the split on Instagram, indicating that disappointing results likely led to the decision.
As the debate continues, fans are left wondering if Spieth needs a fresh voice on the course or if his long-standing partnership with Greller still holds value. Many agree that the ultimate goal is winning, and whether that means sticking with Greller or moving on remains a hot topic of discussion among golf enthusiasts.