Rookies in the NHL often garner significant attention as they try to establish themselves within their respective teams. For the New York Rangers, this is especially true with Brett Berard, a rookie forward currently navigating his first season with the team. Berard has played in 28 games, registering 4 goals and 4 assists, for a total of 8 points. As the Rangers aim for a playoff spot, there’s debate among fans and analysts about whether Berard is being properly developed or if the team is hindering his growth.
One perspective shared by a fan on social media suggests that Berard’s growth would be better served by playing 20 minutes a night in the AHL with the Hartford Wolf Pack, rather than being relegated to limited ice time or sitting in the press box. The concern is that without consistent play, Berard’s development could stall, preventing him from reaching his full potential.
We can debate all day if Brett Berard should or shouldn’t be playing for the Rangers
But what we can’t debate is that Berard is getting more out of playing 20 minutes a night in Hartford than sitting in the press box
Org just seems to always make the wrong decision#NYR
— NYR Louie ™️ (@NYRLouie) March 26, 2025
Despite the strong opinions about the Rangers’ handling of Berard, some fans argue that with the team’s playoff hopes on the line, the focus should be on immediate results rather than long-term development. Others have voiced frustrations with the management’s decisions, including a critique of head coach Peter Laviolette, citing his past struggles with the Washington Capitals as evidence of potential coaching issues.
While there are valid concerns about the team’s development strategy, another fan suggested that the Rangers’ problems extend beyond Berard’s situation, pointing to broader team issues. The team is facing tough competition in the Metropolitan Division, and the question remains: is it worth prioritizing the development of a rookie over a push for the playoffs, or should Berard be given more time in the AHL to refine his skills?