Mickey Moniak’s release by the Angels is another reminder of how unpredictable MLB development can be, especially for former No. 1 overall picks.
While he showed flashes of potential—particularly in 2023 when he posted an .802 OPS in 323 plate appearances—he never fully lived up to the expectations that come with being a top pick. Injuries, inconsistent opportunities, and struggles against left-handed pitching all played a role in his stalled career.
What’s Next for Moniak?
At 26 years old, Moniak still has time to latch on with another team, likely on a minor-league deal with an invite to spring training. Given his speed, defensive ability, and platoon potential, he could appeal to teams looking for outfield depth.
The Phillies, his original team, could be an interesting fit, but it’s unclear if there’s mutual interest. A rebuilding team like the Rockies or Nationals could also take a flier on him.
The 2016 MLB Draft Struggles
The 2016 first round has been historically disappointing, with Nick Senzel playing in Mexico and Ian Anderson struggling to stay healthy. Moniak’s struggles aren’t just a Phillies scouting failure—it was a tough draft year overall.
While Moniak never became the star Philadelphia hoped for, he still made the big leagues, something many top picks never accomplish. His next move will determine if he can carve out a long-term role in the majors or if he becomes another “what could have been” story.