Auston Matthews’ First Season as Maple Leafs Captain: Leadership and Challenges
Auston Matthews assumed the role of captain for the Toronto Maple Leafs before the start of the 2024-25 NHL season, taking over from John Tavares, who stepped down after five years. The decision came following the Maple Leafs’ disappointing first-round exit from the 2024 playoffs, where they lost to their long-time rivals, the Boston Bruins, in Game 7. This defeat led to significant changes within the organization, including the firing of head coach Sheldon Keefe and the hiring of Craig Berube as his replacement.
In addition to the coaching change, the Maple Leafs management felt that Matthews was the right player to lead the team forward, particularly after an impressive individual season where he scored 69 goals. The transition was part of an effort to push the team beyond its playoff struggles and to redefine its leadership core.
Matthews’ Leadership in His First Season as Captain
With 15 games remaining in the regular season, the Maple Leafs hold a record of 40-24-3, sitting third in the Atlantic Division. While they share the same points as the Tampa Bay Lightning, Toronto is currently positioned below them in the standings.
On Wednesday, NHL insider Dave Feschuk discussed Matthews’ leadership role on the “1st Up with Korolnek & Colaiacovo” podcast. He emphasized that while Matthews has shown leadership qualities, true leadership is measured by success when the team faces critical moments.
“Ultimately, (Matthews’) leadership moments that truly matter come when the season is on the line … There’s a reason the Maple Leafs made Auston Matthews captain this offseason,” Feschuk said. “They wanted more from him. Not just as a goal scorer, but as a leader. But until you actually lead a team somewhere, you can’t really be recognized for great leadership.”
The Maple Leafs have endured a rough stretch, losing five out of seven games, including a three-game losing streak. They were at risk of another three-game losing streak before Matthews stepped up, scoring two goals and delivering an inspiring pep talk that helped the team secure a 6–2 victory against the Calgary Flames.
Feschuk noted that while there is still work to be done, the team’s head coach and Matthews’ teammates believe he is handling his leadership responsibilities well. However, he reiterated that the ultimate judgment of Matthews’ leadership will depend on how far the team advances when the playoffs arrive.
Injury Struggles Affecting Matthews’ Performance
Despite taking on the captaincy and proving his leadership abilities, Matthews has faced challenges this season due to injuries. Two months into the campaign, he was sidelined for nine games due to an injury. After briefly returning, he had to miss another six games, and during this period, he traveled to Germany for medical consultations.
During his absence, other key players, such as Mitch Marner and William Nylander, stepped up to maintain the team’s performance. Since returning to the lineup, Matthews has worked on regaining his form. So far, he has recorded 26 goals and 32 assists, totaling 60 points in 52 games.
While Matthews’ first season as captain has had its ups and downs, the team remains in playoff contention. His leadership will ultimately be evaluated based on how the Maple Leafs perform in the postseason, as the organization and its fans continue to seek a deep playoff run.