Why Jalen Milroe Isn’t the Answer for the Steelers in the 2025 NFL Draft
As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, the Pittsburgh Steelers’ quarterback situation remains a hot topic, with Alabama’s Jalen Milroe frequently mentioned as a potential target. However, despite his intriguing skill set, he may not be the right fit for a franchise desperate for stability.
The Case for Milroe
Milroe has many traits that align with the Steelers’ recent quarterback choices, such as Russell Wilson and Justin Fields. His dual-threat ability, combined with a powerful arm, makes him an exciting prospect. Playing in the SEC has also prepared him well for the NFL, given the level of competition he faced.
The Case Against Milroe
While Milroe’s physical tools are impressive, his biggest flaw—consistency—mirrors the very issue that has plagued the Steelers in recent years. At Alabama, he showed flashes of brilliance but also had games where he struggled mightily. The idea that these inconsistencies wouldn’t follow him to the NFL is unrealistic.
The Steelers’ fanbase has grown increasingly frustrated with the team’s lack of direction. Many supporters are already questioning whether head coach Mike Tomlin should continue leading the team. This frustration leaves little room for a long-term quarterback project, especially one with Milroe’s inconsistency.
Pittsburgh Needs a More Reliable Option
At this point, the Steelers require a quarterback who can step in and provide immediate stability, not another boom-or-bust player. Their championship pedigree demands a win-now mentality, making it clear that Milroe may not be the best option in the 2025 draft.