Ohio State’s Quarterback Battle: Julian Sayin vs. Tavien St. Clair – Who Will Be QB1?
Quarterback battles at Ohio State aren’t just about finding the best passer—they’re about setting the tone for the Buckeyes’ championship hopes. With Will Howard gone, Ryan Day faces a decision that could define the 2025 season. The frontrunner? Former 5-star recruit Julian Sayin, who took a detour from Alabama before landing in Columbus. But waiting in the wings is Tavien St. Clair, the in-state phenom with a $1 million NIL valuation.
Julian Sayin: The Proven Talent
Since arriving on campus, Sayin has drawn praise for his accuracy, poise, and arm strength. His final high school season at Carlsbad saw him throw for 2,347 yards, 24 touchdowns, and just one interception while completing 74.5% of his passes. Even former Buckeye QB Will Howard called him “one of the most accurate quarterbacks” he’s ever seen.
Recruiting experts have high expectations, with On3 ranking him as the top QB prospect to watch. But while Sayin’s arm talent is undeniable, insiders have pointed out that he needs to become more vocal as a leader—a challenge that will be put to the test in spring football.
Tavien St. Clair: The Rising Star
If Sayin is the presumed starter, then St. Clair is the biggest wildcard. The 6’4, 210-pound quarterback from Bellefontaine has skyrocketed up recruiting boards, going from a 3-star prospect to a top-3 QB nationally. In his final high school season, he threw for 2,536 yards and 29 touchdowns, proving he’s more than just potential—he’s a serious contender.
Unlike Sayin, who transferred in, St. Clair was personally recruited by Ryan Day from the start. And as the first Ohio native QB to sign with the Buckeyes since Joe Burrow, he carries the hopes of homegrown fans. While many assume he’ll redshirt, his talent and NIL backing suggest he could challenge for playing time sooner than expected.
The Big Question: Who Will Be QB1?
Ryan Day’s decision won’t be easy. Sayin has the experience and elite accuracy, but St. Clair brings raw talent and Ohio roots. And don’t forget about Lincoln Kienholz, the wildcard in this battle.
Who should start for the Buckeyes in 2025? Do you trust Sayin’s polish, or is it time to bet on St. Clair’s upside? Let’s hear your take!