The New York Yankees and their fans started the day hoping for positive news regarding Gerrit Cole’s elbow injury. However, the latest developments have only raised more concerns. Initially, Cole was expected to miss 10-12 weeks without requiring surgery. Now, the situation has escalated, with the Yankees seeking a second opinion—something no team wants to hear when dealing with their ace pitcher.
“This changes the dynamic of where the AL East could be.”@JLEWFifty reacts to the latest news on Gerrit Cole’s health:@Yankees | #Yankees | #RepBX
🔗 https://t.co/iXax8hx4iO pic.twitter.com/JiuRNckt9O— MLB Network Radio on SiriusXM (@MLBNetworkRadio) March 8, 2025
A fully healthy Cole would have been the anchor of the Yankees’ starting rotation, providing much-needed stability for a staff filled with injury risks and inconsistencies. With his absence, Carlos Rodón, Nestor Cortes, Clarke Schmidt, Marcus Stroman, and Luis Gil will have to take on larger roles, leaving the Yankees’ pitching situation more vulnerable than before.
Former MLB pitcher and analyst Jensen Lewis did not hold back in his assessment of the situation, suggesting that the worst-case scenario might be unfolding. He stated that the Yankees’ front office, including general manager Brian Cashman and owner Hal Steinbrenner, is likely already discussing backup plans, indicating that the team is not optimistic about Cole’s immediate return.
When teams rush their star pitchers to a second doctor, it usually means something concerning was found in the initial diagnosis. The first evaluation had recommended rest and rehabilitation over surgery, but the need for further consultation raises two possibilities—either the first doctor was not entirely convinced by the original plan, or Cole’s symptoms have worsened. Neither scenario bodes well for the Yankees. If surgery becomes necessary, the team will lose their reigning Cy Young winner for the entire 2025 season and possibly part of 2026.
The Yankees’ Rotation Without Cole
With Cole sidelined, the Yankees’ rotation becomes a mix of potential and uncertainty. Carlos Rodón has the ability to perform at a high level but struggled with injuries last season. Nestor Cortes is returning from a lost year, and Marcus Stroman, while reliable, is better suited as a mid-rotation starter rather than the ace. Meanwhile, Clarke Schmidt and Luis Gil, though talented, are largely unproven in high-pressure situations.
The Yankees now face a crucial decision—do they trust their current rotation, or do they explore the trade market to acquire another front-line starter? If Cole’s second opinion confirms an extended absence, the Yankees may have no choice but to make an aggressive move.
Potential Trade Targets
Jensen Lewis mentioned that the Yankees could look at acquiring Sandy Alcantara, although he is currently recovering from Tommy John surgery. Other possible trade candidates include Shane Bieber, Dylan Cease, and Corbin Burnes if their respective teams make them available. If the Yankees were planning on making a deep playoff run with Cole as their ace, they may need to reconsider their strategy altogether.
Impact on the AL East Race
Cole’s uncertain status has major implications for the AL East. The Yankees rely on their pitching depth, as well as offensive firepower from Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. However, with the rotation now filled with question marks, the pressure increases on position players like Anthony Volpe, Gleyber Torres, and offseason acquisition Alex Verdugo.
Meanwhile, the Baltimore Orioles, who have been improving steadily, now have an even greater opportunity to take control of the division. Their rotation, featuring Kyle Bradish and Grayson Rodriguez, is trending upward. The Toronto Blue Jays, while relatively quiet during the offseason, still have a strong pitching staff led by Kevin Gausman and José Berríos, along with an offense powered by Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette. Additionally, the Tampa Bay Rays continue to be a threat due to their ability to maximize talent and exceed expectations.
If Cole’s injury keeps him out for a significant period—or worse, if he requires surgery—the Yankees may be forced to make a move early in the season. Otherwise, they risk falling behind in what is shaping up to be one of baseball’s most competitive divisions. The question now is how the Yankees will adjust to remain a contender without their $324 million ace leading the rotation.