This situation with Pete Alonso and the Mets is a fascinating case study in balancing loyalty, financial strategy, and legacy in professional sports. Both sides are playing a high-stakes game, with Steve Cohen prioritizing long-term goals for the franchise and Alonso, under the guidance of Scott Boras, striving for respect and a lucrative deal.
From a fan’s perspective, it’s easy to sympathize with Alonso’s contributions—192 home runs since 2019 is no small feat. But Cohen’s position makes sense as well. He has to think beyond emotions and look at the sustainability of the roster. It’s not just about retaining a star but ensuring the franchise doesn’t become financially hamstrung down the line.
If Alonso does leave, especially to a team like the Blue Jays, it will undoubtedly sting for Mets fans, but Cohen’s comment—”If he is not back, that is his loss”—shows his confidence in the broader plan for the team. Meanwhile, Boras’s insistence on fairness could be a double-edged sword, risking Alonso’s reputation with the fanbase.
Very happy for David Stearns and Steve Cohen standing their ground today. They had fantastic answers. This is their team. They run the ship. They have been fair to Alonso. If he’s not back, so be it. The Mets will be fine without him.
I love this owner, front office and…
— Jake Brown (@JakeBrownRadio) January 26, 2025
What do you think? Should the Mets take a calculated risk and stand firm, or is Alonso’s presence irreplaceable for the franchise’s future?