As Texas gears up for its Peach Bowl College Football Playoff quarterfinal against Arizona State, the spotlight remains on the ongoing debate surrounding quarterbacks Quinn Ewers and Arch Manning. This discourse gained momentum when Ewers was sidelined with an injury earlier in the season, giving Manning the opportunity to shine. Manning delivered a stellar performance, leading Texas to a dominant 56-7 victory over UTSA, throwing four touchdowns and rushing for 67 yards. This sparked speculation about whether it was time for Texas head coach Steve Sarkisian to move on from Ewers in favor of Manning.
The conversation has persisted, with many believing that Manning’s rise signals the end of Ewers’ tenure as Texas’ starting quarterback. Ahead of this crucial quarterfinal, college football analyst Todd McShay weighed in, offering a strong opinion on the matter.
Quinn Ewers’ Season and Challenges
Ewers had a season filled with highs and lows. While he showcased brilliance at times, such as a near-perfect performance against Clemson in the playoff opener, he also struggled in key games, notably against Georgia. Ewers’ inability to evade sacks, exacerbated by an ankle injury, drew criticism from fans, who began clamoring for Manning to take over.
Despite these setbacks, Ewers led Texas to an impressive 12-2 record, securing the best finish in the Southeastern Conference and setting up a playoff showdown against Arizona State. Sarkisian’s patience with Ewers has been a testament to his confidence in the quarterback, but the rising talent of Manning presents a dilemma that cannot be ignored.
McShay’s Take: Is It Time for Arch Manning?
McShay firmly believes that the upcoming Peach Bowl will mark the end of Ewers’ era at Texas. According to him, regardless of whether the season concludes with a national championship or disappointment, it’s time for Arch Manning to take center stage. McShay stated that Ewers’ future lies elsewhere, suggesting he should explore opportunities in the NFL or transfer to another program to refine his skills.
Drawing comparisons to players like Michael Penix Jr., Bo Nix, and Jaden Daniels, who thrived after transferring, McShay argued that Ewers could benefit from a fresh start. Another year in college, under a different system, could help Ewers rebuild his draft stock, which has fallen from first-round projections to a mid-round grade. McShay emphasized that such a move could offer Ewers the game experience and development he needs to succeed at the next level.
Joel Klatt’s Concerns
Fox analyst Joel Klatt expressed skepticism about Ewers’ ability to deliver under pressure in the upcoming matchup against Arizona State. While he acknowledged Texas’ overall strength as a national title contender, Klatt questioned whether Ewers could ignite the team’s passing game when it mattered most. However, Klatt suggested that if Texas could excel in other aspects of the game, Ewers might have a chance to prove his worth.
The Road Ahead for Quinn Ewers
Ewers faces a pivotal moment in his career. Whether he decides to enter the NFL draft, transfer to another program, or return to Texas for another year, the outcome of the Peach Bowl could significantly impact his trajectory. Ending the season on a high note, possibly with a national championship, could bolster his prospects and give him the fresh start he needs.
As the debate continues, one thing is clear: Texas must carefully navigate this critical juncture. The decision between Ewers and Manning will shape the future of the Longhorns and determine whether they remain contenders on the national stage.