Kirby Smart has undeniably transformed the Georgia Bulldogs into one of the top programs in college football, closely mirroring the success of his former mentor, Nick Saban, at Alabama. Smart’s formula for success has been built on a dominant defense, a deep stable of running backs, and a quarterback who can manage the game without making critical mistakes. This approach led to back-to-back national championships, with Stetson Bennett’s steady, error-free play at quarterback being a key component of Georgia’s recent dominance.
However, this season has presented a different set of challenges for the Bulldogs, particularly at the quarterback position. After Bennett’s departure, Carson Beck was expected to seamlessly step into the starting role and maintain Georgia’s offensive balance. Yet, Beck has struggled with inconsistency, often plagued by turnovers—most notably multiple three-interception games. This inconsistency has left the Bulldogs vulnerable at times and raised doubts about their chances of securing a third national championship in four years.
Things took a turn for the worse in the SEC Championship, where Beck suffered an elbow injury, leaving Smart with no choice but to turn to sophomore quarterback Gunner Stockton. Stockton has shown flashes of potential, but his inexperience was evident, particularly during his brief stint against Texas, where he threw an interception. As the postseason approaches, the uncertainty surrounding Georgia’s quarterback play has become a central storyline, with questions about their championship aspirations growing louder.
ESPN’s Todd McShay summed it up perfectly: “There isn’t a bigger question mark going into the College Football Playoff than Carson Beck’s health. Period.” With Beck’s status uncertain and no clear timetable for his return, Smart will need to lean heavily on Stockton, who must deliver strong, mistake-free play if Georgia hopes to make another deep run. Fortunately, the first-round bye in the playoff provides Smart with extra time to prepare Stockton and the rest of the offense.
Adding to Georgia’s relative good fortune, their side of the playoff bracket appears more manageable than some others, with potential matchups against Boise State, Notre Dame, Indiana, Penn State, and SMU. If Stockton can execute Smart’s game plan effectively—primarily focusing on limiting mistakes while leaning on Georgia’s dominant defense and running game—the Bulldogs may still have a path to their third national title in as many years.
Ultimately, Georgia’s fate hinges on their quarterback play. Whether it’s Carson Beck’s recovery or Gunner Stockton’s growth, Smart’s postseason decisions will be critical. With their defense and overall talent, Georgia remains a dangerous team, but quarterback play—always a pivotal factor—has never been more important as they push for another championship.