The Complex Case of Jalen Milroe: Transfer Portal or Redemption?
Jalen Milroe, once celebrated for his contributions to Alabama in 2023, is now under intense scrutiny. The quarterback’s struggles in 2024 have sparked debates among analysts and fans alike, with his performance against Oklahoma standing out as particularly alarming. Completing just 42% of his passes (11 of 26) in that game has many questioning his readiness for both another season with Alabama and a potential future in the NFL.
Damien Harris Calls for a Bold Move
Ex-Alabama running back Damien Harris recently added his voice to the discussion, suggesting that Milroe should consider entering the transfer portal rather than declaring for the NFL draft. Harris stated:
“I don’t think he should go to the draft because I don’t think he is NFL-ready. I think you should hit the transfer portal.”
This candid critique underscores the challenges Milroe faces and hints at a lack of confidence in his ability to succeed at the next level in his current form.
A Tale of Two Sides: Rushing vs. Passing
Milroe’s strengths as a quarterback lie in his rushing abilities, as evidenced by his four rushing touchdowns against LSU and two against Georgia. However, his limitations as a passer became glaring in games like the one against Oklahoma, where his accuracy and decision-making faltered. Critics have pointed fingers at Alabama’s offensive coordinator, Nick Sheridan, for utilizing Milroe in a passing-heavy scheme against Oklahoma, but as a quarterback, some level of consistency in the air is expected.
Is the NFL a Realistic Option?
Milroe’s NFL prospects look grim at the moment. Teams in the league are well-equipped to counter rushing quarterbacks, as demonstrated by how easily Oklahoma neutralized him. While the NFL does offer access to top-tier coaching, Milroe’s current skill set suggests he would face significant challenges adapting to the professional game.
The Transfer Portal: A Fresh Start?
The transfer portal presents a potential lifeline for Milroe. With quarterbacks like Carson Beck (Georgia) and Shedeur Sanders (Colorado) expected to declare for the NFL draft, opportunities could open up in teams across the SEC. Georgia, for instance, will need to rebuild its quarterback depth with Beck sidelined due to injury. Milroe could step into a system that better suits his strengths, especially if paired with a coach adept at developing quarterbacks.
Potential Landing Spots and Kalen DeBoer’s Role
If Milroe does decide to transfer, he could find success under a coach like Kalen DeBoer, known for his work with Michael Penix Jr. DeBoer’s offense is well-equipped with weapons, and a quarterback like Conner Weigman (if healthy) could also be an ideal fit for his system. Milroe’s rushing prowess, combined with a more tailored offensive strategy, could revive his college career.
The Impact of Losing Milroe
While Milroe’s departure would hurt Alabama, it might be necessary for both his growth and the team’s development. Alabama’s offense has shown inconsistencies, with promising wide receivers like Kendrick Law and Kobe Prentice not fully utilized. A revamped system that doesn’t revolve entirely around the quarterback could benefit the team.
Conclusion: What’s Next for Jalen Milroe?
Jalen Milroe’s future is at a crossroads. Should he stay with Alabama and work toward redemption, or should he enter the transfer portal for a fresh start? While his rushing ability is undeniable, his struggles as a passer highlight the need for significant improvement before considering the NFL. A change in environment, with the right coaching staff, could be the key to unlocking his full potential.
Regardless of the path he chooses, Milroe’s journey will be closely watched by fans and analysts alike.