A former Rugby World Cup-winning coach has expressed his opinion that New Zealand Rugby (NZR) would make a significant mistake by altering its current policy on overseas-based players. Currently, only players competing domestically in New Zealand are eligible for selection in the All Blacks. However, the incoming head coach, Scott Robertson, has indicated his intention to challenge this policy, suggesting that some foreign-based players should be allowed to represent the national team.
The coach argued against such changes, cautioning that it could undermine the longstanding values and traditions that have defined New Zealand rugby. He emphasized that the All Blacks’ mystique and aura, built over generations, would be at risk if the policy were adjusted. He believes that making exceptions for even one player, such as Richie Mo’unga, would set a dangerous precedent.
The coach acknowledged the frustration felt by New Zealand following recent challenges, including a narrow loss to France and a less-than-dominant performance against Italy during the Rugby World Cup. Despite this, he argued that bringing in overseas players is not a simple solution to their desire to reclaim their status as the world’s best team.
A former All Blacks fly-half, who famously contributed to their 2011 World Cup victory, also opposed the proposed policy change, emphasizing the importance of sacrifice. The fly-half stated that representing the All Blacks should remain an ultimate honor that requires significant commitment, particularly as the team has upheld this standard for over a century.
Although South Africa has achieved success in recent years, winning two consecutive World Cups after lifting restrictions on selecting overseas players, the coach does not believe that New Zealand should follow this example. He argued that while rugby trends fluctuate, New Zealand has traditionally excelled due to its robust talent pool, bolstered by contributions from Pacific Island nations.
Reflecting on past experiences, the coach recalled matches where Pacific Island players featured prominently for both their home nations and the All Blacks due to more flexible eligibility rules at the time. He highlighted that the envy other countries felt for New Zealand’s ability to produce world-class talent stemmed from their commitment to domestic player development, a strength he believes should not be compromised.
In conclusion, the coach warned that altering the overseas player policy could erode the values and systems that have made New Zealand rugby exceptional, urging caution in any decision to modify this foundational principle.