Alabama quarterback Jalen Milroe’s season has been a rollercoaster, with highs that showcased his immense potential and lows that have left fans questioning his future with the team—and even in football altogether. Starting the season as a hot topic in Heisman Trophy discussions and NFL draft projections, Milroe’s performances have significantly dipped in recent weeks. This decline has sparked debates about his readiness for the professional league and his place in Alabama’s plans moving forward.
Should Jalen Milroe run it back with Alabama next season? pic.twitter.com/DGmogT14ng
— College Football Report (@CFBRep) November 24, 2024
The situation escalated on November 24, when College Football Report posted a picture of Milroe with the question, “Should Jalen Milroe run it back with Alabama next season?” This sparked a wave of criticism, as fans voiced their frustration over his inconsistency. While some acknowledged his potential, many expressed doubts about his NFL readiness, with some suggesting he might not be the best fit for Alabama anymore. Fans debated whether he should stay and prove himself, transfer to another college for a fresh start, or even declare for the NFL draft despite his struggles.
Milroe’s early-season performances were promising, with completion rates over 70%. However, as the season progressed, his accuracy dropped, including a disappointing 55% against Tennessee. Despite these struggles, ESPN’s latest mock draft still ranks him as a first-round pick, projecting him as the No. 28 overall selection to the Pittsburgh Steelers. This optimism from analysts has only intensified criticism from fans, many of whom question whether he deserves such high praise after a midseason slump.
Milroe has shown glimpses of his talent in key moments. For instance, he completed 61% of his passes in a commanding 34-0 win against Missouri, despite facing significant pressure and being sacked multiple times. He also played a crucial role in Alabama’s blowout victory over LSU, demonstrating his capability to lead the team against tough opponents. However, such highlights have been overshadowed by inconsistent performances in other games, particularly in Alabama’s shocking loss to the 6-5 Oklahoma Sooners. In that game, Milroe completed less than 50% of his passes, threw three interceptions, and failed to score a touchdown, leaving fans questioning his ability to perform under pressure.
Fans’ criticism has been sharp, with some suggesting Milroe isn’t ready for the NFL and would benefit from another college season—whether at Alabama or elsewhere as a graduate transfer. Others have been more critical, bluntly stating that Alabama might be better off without him. Despite the backlash, Milroe’s dual-threat capabilities remain noteworthy. Last season, he rushed for 600 yards, scored nine rushing touchdowns, and led Alabama to an SEC championship, finishing sixth in the Heisman Trophy race. However, this season’s struggles have led to some fans branding him as an “imposter” or a “counterfeit Milroe.”
While many are skeptical about his current draft stock, some supporters remain hopeful. Milroe’s natural talent and moments of brilliance suggest he has the tools to succeed. One subpar season doesn’t define a career, and his ability to bounce back could prove his critics wrong. Whether he chooses to stay at Alabama, transfer to another college, or declare for the NFL draft, Milroe still has opportunities to redefine his narrative and fulfill his potential.