The race to sign Juan Soto has brought in some heavyweight contenders, with the New York Yankees and New York Mets leading the pack. However, the Boston Red Sox have emerged as an unexpected player in this high-stakes sweepstakes. Historically known for their conservative spending and focus on developing young talent, the Red Sox’s potential interest in a player who could command $600 million has raised eyebrows and fueled speculation about their true intentions.
This sudden shift in strategy has sparked debate. Many believe the Red Sox might simply be stirring the pot, particularly given their storied rivalry with the Yankees. MLB analyst Mike Giardi expressed skepticism about Boston’s willingness to make such a hefty financial commitment, stating, “There is no way in hell they are going to pay this man this money.” However, Red Sox legend David Ortiz, affectionately known as Big Papi, has pushed back against this notion, asserting that the team is genuinely pursuing Soto.
Ortiz has been a vocal advocate for bringing Soto to Fenway Park. When asked to make a quick pitch to Soto about why he should join the Red Sox, Ortiz confidently outlined the team’s commitment. He claimed to be personally involved in understanding the team’s strategy, saying, “They’re not faking it. Trust me, I’m trying to do my homework also to see if we can hire him because that’s what Mr. Henry wants… They are trying hard.” Ortiz further emphasized the potential fit for Soto, describing Fenway Park as a place where the player would feel at home, particularly with Ortiz himself as a mentor.
“They’re not faking it. Trust me I’m trying to do my homework also to see if we can hire him, because that’s what Mr. Henry wants … They are trying hard.”
– David Ortiz on the Red Sox pursuit of Juan Soto (via @BBisntBoring) pic.twitter.com/LNPpWDXde5
— Boston Sports Gordo (@BOSSportsGordo) November 22, 2024
Despite Ortiz’s assurances, some analysts remain unconvinced. Team owner John Henry’s absence from a key meeting with Soto could hurt the Red Sox’s chances, especially since Soto reportedly values a direct connection with ownership. Columnist Jon Heyman suggested this might be a significant misstep by Boston in their bid for the superstar.
Meanwhile, the New York teams appear to be making stronger pushes. Both the Yankees and Mets had their respective owners present during their meetings with Soto. MLB insider Ken Rosenthal speculated that the Mets, under owner Steve Cohen, have the financial power to outbid everyone else. Cohen’s willingness to spend heavily may be the deciding factor, with Rosenthal saying, “If I were a betting man, that’s the way I would bet.” Michael Kay added that the Yankees are unlikely to go beyond $50 million per year, potentially ceding ground to the Mets, who seem ready to top any offer.
However, surprises are common during the MLB offseason, and no team can be ruled out just yet. Some believe the Dodgers could also make a strong play for Soto, given their deep pockets and championship aspirations.
As debates rage on, questions remain: Are the Red Sox truly serious about signing Soto, or is this a publicity stunt aimed at unsettling their rivals? Should the team take the financial risk, especially if it means surpassing the Competitive Balance Tax? For now, the answer lies in the hands of Soto and the teams vying for his signature.